Blue Nile Canada 2024: Newbie Buying Guide (Taxes and Fees)

Author picture

Have a question? Not sure which one is the right diamond?

contact us

My blog is reader-supported; when you purchase through links on my site, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. This enables me to provide you with free content.

Some retailers understand that the diamond buying process can be overwhelming. For that reason they are willing to share a portion of their profits with me if I can make this experience more simple for you.

In this partnership, you benefit from complimentary content and personalized consultations. If all sides are happy and you decide to buy, the retailer (and not you) compensates me.

While many diamond retailers have approached me, I hold the highest standards, choosing to collaborate only with those whose services and pricing I can confidently endorse. Your satisfaction and access to quality service are my top priorities. Therefore, you can trust that I maintain an unbiased perspective, without compromising the integrity of this blog.

blue nile review featured image new

Quick Overview

  • Blue Nile Canada offers competitive prices, free resizing services and complimentary shipping with varying timeframes.

  • Customers should be aware of import fees & taxes applicable to their province of residence. Blue Nile acts as the ‘Importer of Record’ for Canadian customers simplifying the process by handling taxes and ensuring compliance with customs regulations.

  • Blue Nile provides ethically sourced diamonds at competitive prices, exceptional packaging & presentation plus the best 360 videos for diamond inspection.

Get $50 Off Instantly at Blue Nile

Deal Alerts!


25% Off Sitewide + Up to 50% off The Initial Collection at James Allen

Up to 50% OFF Selected Jewelry at Blue Nile

Instant $100 off when signing up + 3% discount on wire transfer at Whiteflash

Table of Contents

Are you considering Blue Nile Canada for your next diamond purchase but unsure what to expect in terms of quality, pricing, and selection? Look no further, as we have ventured into the depths of Blue Nile to unearth the best it has to offer and provide you with an in-depth review. From navigating import fees and taxes to exploring exclusive designer collections, we will guide you through every step of the Blue Nile experience, ensuring you make an informed decision for your next dazzling acquisition.

Navigating Import Fees and Taxes for Blue Nile Canada

When shopping for that perfect diamond ring or piece of jewelry on Blue Nile Canada, it’s crucial to be aware of potential import fees and taxes when ordering from the US, as the applicable provincial taxes may vary.

The ‘Subtotal. Duty-free’ prices on Blue Nile’s website do not include the provincial tax. Instead, the tax amount is determined based on the province of residence of the customer.

blue nile canada checkout tax calculation

Understanding Provincial Taxes

To avoid any unpleasant surprises in your shopping experience, it’s essential to understand the taxes Blue Nile collects. They collect GST/HST and Quebec PST on the taxable value of all orders shipped to customers in Canada.

By being informed about these provincial taxes, you can accurately calculate the final cost of your purchase and avoid unexpected fees.

Blue Nile Canada engagement rings

Blue Nile as the 'Importer of Record' for Canadian Customers

In addition to navigating import fees and taxes, it’s important to know that Blue Nile serves as the ‘Importer of Record’ for Canadian customers. But what does this role entail? As the ‘Importer of Record’, Blue Nile is obligated to guarantee that all imported goods adhere to all customs and legal regulations of the country of import. This involves paying any applicable taxes and duties, as well as ensuring that all documentation is completed accurately.

By acting as the ‘Importer of Record’, Blue Nile simplifies the process for Canadian customers, handling taxes and ensuring compliance with customs regulations. This allows you to focus on selecting the perfect piece of jewelry without worrying about the complexities of cross-border transactions.

Blue Nile canada diamond rings

Shipping Considerations for Blue Nile Canada

Another crucial aspect to consider when shopping on Blue Nile is free shipping everywhere. Blue Nile provides complimentary shipping to Canada via FedEx or UPS, and the package will be sent in discreet packaging for security and surprise.

Delivery timeframes may vary depending on the province, but the efficiency of Blue Nile’s diamond sourcing and pairing with the ring setting ensures a smooth process.

Shipping Costs and Carriers

When it comes to shipping costs and carriers, Blue Nile has you covered. They provide complimentary, reliable shipping with every order using FedEx or UPS for shipping.

This means you can enjoy shopping for your dream ring or piece of diamond jewelry without worrying about additional shipping costs or unreliable carrier shipping times.

Delivery Time frames

As for delivery timeframes, Blue Nile Canada’s estimated delivery times range from 1-5 days depending on the province. By the online retailer utilizing FedEx and UPS for shipping, you can trust that your order will arrive in a timely manner. Ensuring you receive your precious purchase promptly and without delay.

Returns and Resizing Policies for Blue Nile Canada

In the event that your purchase doesn’t meet your expectations or requires resizing, Blue Nile offers a 30-day return policy and a one-year warranty on new items, plus a lifetime warranty on diamond jewelry. They also provide complimentary resizing for the first year of your ring. This means you can shop with confidence knowing that Blue Nile has your back if any issues arise.

When returning a ring for resizing, it will be shipped to a Blue Nile fulfillment center within Canada, allowing customers to avoid any potential taxes when the ring is returned. This thoughtful approach to resizing ensures a hassle-free experience for Canadian customers.

Free Resizing Services

Blue Nile offers complimentary ring resizing on all customized engagement rings within the first year, as well as free resizing for most engagement rings and wedding bands within the manufacturer’s recommended sizing range during the first year. To help you determine the perfect ring size, Blue Nile even provides an education section with tips on how to accurately measure your ring size.

The convenience of free resizing services ensures that your ring will fit perfectly, making your purchase even more special.

Blue Nile Lab-Created Diamonds

If you’re looking for an eco-friendly and cost-effective alternative to mined diamonds, consider Blue Nile’s lab-created diamonds. These diamonds are crafted to the same exacting standards as mined diamonds but are 40%-70% less expensive and offer larger diamonds with fewer inclusions. This means you can enjoy a larger, more brilliant diamond without sacrificing quality or your budget.

Furthermore, Blue Nile lab diamonds are produced in a controlled environment, resulting in a higher level of purity and fewer defects in their crystal structure. Blue Nile has the largest selection of GIA-certified lab-grown diamonds worldwide, ensuring the highest quality.

Blue Nile's Exclusive Designer Collections and Customization Options

One example of the many reasons to choose Blue Nile for your next diamond purchase is its exclusive designer collections and customization options. Blue Nile offers stunning engagement rings and jewelry from renowned designers such as Colin Cowie, Monique Lhuillier, and Zac Posen. These exclusive collections allow you to choose a unique, one-of-a-kind piece that perfectly captures your personal style and love story.

In addition to its designer collections, Blue Nile also offers an extensive inventory of diamonds and settings, thanks to its exclusive agreements with some of the most prominent diamond wholesalers worldwide. With over 200,000 natural diamonds in stock, you can enjoy a fantastic selection and the ability to create a truly customized piece of jewelry that reflects your individual taste and preferences.

The Online Shopping Experience on Blue Nile

The online shopping experience on Blue Nile is modern and upscale, providing a seamless and enjoyable shopping journey for customers. Their knowledgeable and helpful salespeople are available to assist you with any questions or concerns, ensuring that you feel confident in your purchase.

In addition to their exceptional customer service, Blue Nile has recently incorporated videos into their online shopping experience, further enhancing the ability to view and evaluate the beauty of their diamonds. With a contemporary design and a laid-back atmosphere, Blue Nile’s online store offers a unique and enjoyable experience for those in search of the perfect piece of diamond jewelry.

Ethically Sourced Diamonds and Blue Nile's Business Model

Blue Nile’s revolutionary business model prioritizes ethical sourcing, accredited diamonds, and price matching, setting them apart from other online retailers. As the preeminent provider of online jewelry sales, Blue Nile’s commitment to ethical sourcing and its extensive inventory at minimal margins provide customers with greater value than traditional retailers.

By displaying diamonds virtually directly from diamond manufacturers and wholesalers, Blue Nile offers an extensive inventory of diamonds at competitive prices. This ensures that you can shop with confidence, knowing that you’re investing in a high-quality, ethically sourced diamond at the best possible price.

blue nile store

Blue Nile Packaging and Presentation

When it comes to packaging and presentation, Blue Nile goes above and beyond to ensure your purchase arrives in style. Their high-quality packaging and discreet shipping protect your purchase while maintaining the element of surprise.

With a full history, a strong commitment to customer satisfaction and a reputation for excellence in the diamond jewelry industry, Blue Nile has established itself as the go-to online destination for those in search of the perfect diamond. From their exclusive designer collections to their lab-created diamonds, Blue Nile offers a shopping experience that is truly unmatched.

blue nile diamond inspection

Conclusion - My Personal Experience

In conclusion, Blue Nile Canada delivers an exceptional shopping experience, offering high-quality, ethically sourced diamonds and exclusive designer and diamond jewellery collections at competitive prices. With their revolutionary business model, commitment to customer satisfaction, and extensive inventory of diamonds and settings, Blue Nile has become the premier choice for those seeking the perfect piece of diamond jewelry.

While a substantial portion of my clientele is based in the US, a notable amount of customers from Canada also turn to me for advice when choosing diamonds from Blue Nile. This has given me a first-hand insight into their experience as Blue Nile’s customers. The feedback has been overwhelmingly positive, with the import process being a breeze. Blue Nile takes on the task of managing all complexities involved. The customers have a clear-cut role – settling the charges and eagerly awaiting the arrival of their diamond at their doorstep. It’s as simple as that.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, Blue Nile does ship to Canada, as it is required to collect GST/HST, Quebec PST, and additional duties and PST from customers in Canada.

No, Blue Nile is not a Canadian Company. It was founded in Seattle, Washington, and has since become a subsidiary of Bain Capital. Most recently, in 2022, it was acquired by Signet Jewellers.

Blue Nile keeps their prices low by providing a variety of diamonds in different quality levels so that customers can choose the diamond they want at a price that suits their budget.

Furthermore, Blue Nile cuts out many of the costs associated with buying diamonds from physical stores by only selling online.

Based on customer reviews, GIA independent laboratory testing, and decades of experience in the diamond industry, Blue Nile is indeed a legitimate diamond source. They provide top-quality diamonds at unbeatable prices, backed by solid return policies and industry-leading customer service.

Looking For a Diamond?

Let me do the hard work for you

Best Place to Buy Natural and Lab-Grown Diamonds

My no-nonsense reviews are based on my personal experiences, knowledge, and high standards. Explore my top-rated critiques of leading diamond sellers, curated to help you make the best choice.

Author: Yaniv Hadar

Looking For a Diamond?

I'm On Your Side.

Find the most valuable diamond within your budget, without risking your money and wasting time on research.





Do you want help picking the best diamond?