fbpx ...

GIA Lab-Grown Diamonds: Are They Overrated?

My blog is reader supported. When you buy with my links, I may earn a commission. Learn more.

Because of that I also offer free diamond consultation, a Win-Win for both of us. Need help? Contact me here.

gia lab grown diamonds featured image

In this article

Bottom Line

GIA (Gemological Institute of America) is the gold standard in diamond certification. But when it comes to lab-grown diamonds? They’re not exactly the top pick. Most buyers are leaning towards International Gemological Institute (IGI) lab diamonds. Why? IGI brings something crucial to the table – clear information about the diamond growth process. They tell you whether it’s HPHT or CVD. GIA? not giving out that info.

So what’s GIA’s angle? Prestige. Pure and simple. The price difference between GIA and IGI certs is tiny – we’re talking 0.4-4%. But that GIA name? It carries weight. From my experience, about 20% of buyers still go for GIA lab diamonds. It’s like a safety blanket – they trust the name, they trust the cert.

So, where should you shop? I’ve got some recommendations:

  • Want a mix of IGI and GIA certified lab-grown diamonds? This trusted seller is your go-to. They’ve got a well-curated stock with quality that’ll make your eyes pop.

  • Looking for the biggest selection and wallet-friendly prices? Check out this retailer – it’s my personal favorite. They’ve always got more options and prices that’ll make you do a double-take.

  • Want the best of both worlds – premium cut and budget-friendly options? This particular retailer has got you covered.

Test yourself: Is this diamond natural or lab-grown?

(So… let’s see if I can trick you!)

Today Best Price

Most Affordable

1.0 Carat D VVS1 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$1,470
$1,470/ct
Underpriced
AFlink

Best Balance

1.5 Carat E VS1 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$2,090
$1,393/ct
Underpriced
AFlink

Large Option

2.0 Carat D VS1 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$2,850
$1,425/ct
AFlink

Premium

2.01 Carat D VVS2 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$3,750
$1,866/ct
Hearts and Arrows
AFlink

Table of Contents

What Are GIA Lab-Grown Diamonds?

Simply put, GIA lab-grown diamonds are diamonds created in a controlled laboratory environment and certified by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA). Each one comes with a GIA certification – evaluating the diamond’s grades. Think of it as the diamond’s birth certificate. The importance of diamond quality cannot be overstated, as the 4 Cs—cut, color, clarity, and carat weight—significantly affect the value of lab-grown diamonds.

Why the need for certification? The diamond market has become increasingly complex, with various types of diamonds and diamond simulants available. GIA certification helps distinguish genuine lab-grown diamonds from other materials that might look similar to the untrained eye. Cubic zirconia, a common diamond simulant, differs significantly from lab-grown diamonds in terms of optical and physical characteristics.

What Is The GIA?

The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) isn’t just another player in the diamond game—it’s the referee. Founded back in 1931, GIA has become the gold standard in diamond grading and education. Their mission? To ensure the highest standards of excellence in gemology through research, education, and grading services.

GIA’s expert grading practices have shaped the industry’s standards. They’re the go-to authority for jewelers, collectors, and consumers worldwide. Why? Because they’ve built a reputation for unwavering credibility over decades.

But GIA isn’t stuck in the past. They’ve constantly adapted and improved their grading systems to reflect advancements in technology, ethics, and market trends. Their commitment to unbiased diamond evaluation ensures integrity, fairness, and transparent reporting that you can bank on.

2.01 Carat D VS1 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$2,860
$1,423/ct
Underpriced
AFlink
2.01 Carat D VS2 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$2,860
$1,423/ct
Underpriced
AFlink
2.01 Carat D VS1 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$2,860
$1,423/ct
Underpriced
AFlink

Why GIA Certification Matters

A GIA certification isn’t just a piece of paper—it’s a promise of accurate grading. When you’re buying a diamond, a GIA certification adds a level of confidence to your purchase. Here’s why GIA certification matters:

  1. Strict Grading System: GIA’s longstanding reputation is built on their rigorous and consistent grading criteria. Their reports are respected throughout the industry—from consumers to retailers to appraisers.

  2. Fair Pricing Assurance: A GIA certificate helps ensure you’re paying a fair price for the diamond’s characteristics. It evaluates the diamond based on established criteria, including the famous 4 Cs: Carat, Color, Clarity, and Cut.

  3. Transparency: GIA reports provide detailed information about your diamond’s characteristics. This allows you to make an informed decision, knowing exactly what you’re getting.

It’s important to note: GIA certification doesn’t guarantee quality, but it does guarantee that you know what you’re paying for. It’s a tool that helps both customers and sellers evaluate diamonds accurately.

GIA Grading System for Lab-Grown Diamonds

The 4 Cs Explained

If you’re diving into the world of diamonds, you’ve got to get familiar with the 4 Cs, which are crucial to understanding diamond quality. These are the foundational qualities that define a diamond’s value and beauty. Let’s break them down:

  1. Carat: Carat is all about weight. One carat equals 200 milligrams. Here’s the thing—more carats often mean a bigger diamond, but it doesn’t always translate to higher value. Rarity and demand for specific characteristics play a huge role too.

  2. Color: When it comes to diamond color, less is more. The color grading scale starts at D (colorless) and goes all the way to Z (light yellow or brown). The more colorless the diamond, the higher its value. These rare, colorless diamonds show off their brilliance like no other.

  3. Clarity: Clarity is all about how clean your diamond looks. GIA grades clarity on a scale from Flawless (no inclusions visible under 10x magnification) to Included (inclusions visible to the naked eye).

Pro tip: When you’re shopping for a diamond, consider going for one in the VS1 to VS2 range. These stones give you an excellent balance of clarity and value.

  1. Cut: The cut of a diamond is where the magic happens. It’s not just about the shape—it’s about how well the diamond has been cut to reflect light. GIA grades cut quality based on proportions, symmetry, and polish. A well-cut diamond is like a light show on your finger. It allows light to enter the diamond and reflect beautifully, making it the star of the show.

The Cons of the GIA Lab-Grown Diamonds Grading System

While GIA’s grading system is highly respected, there are drawbacks when it comes to lab-grown diamonds:

  1. Lack of Growth Method Disclosure: GIA does not disclose whether the diamond was grown using HPHT (High Pressure High Temperature) or CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition) methods. This information can be valuable for consumers who have preferences or concerns about specific growth processes.

  2. No Information on Post-Growth Treatments: GIA doesn’t reveal if the diamond underwent any post-growth treatments. These treatments can significantly affect a diamond’s characteristics, and many consumers consider this information crucial for making an informed purchase.

These limitations in GIA’s reporting for lab-grown diamonds may leave some buyers wanting more transparency. Lab made diamonds are graded using the same criteria as natural diamonds, but GIA’s lack of disclosure on growth methods can be a drawback. It’s important to weigh these factors when deciding between GIA and other certification options for lab-grown diamonds.

2.01 Carat D VVS2 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$3,750
$1,866/ct
Hearts and Arrows
AFlink
2.02 Carat D VVS1 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$4,641
$2,298/ct
Hearts and Arrows
AFlink
2.03 Carat D VVS1 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$4,683
$2,307/ct
Hearts and Arrows
AFlink

How to Read a GIA Lab Diamonds Report

Key Sections of the Report

A GIA report is your diamond’s detailed profile. Here’s how to interpret the key information it provides:

  1. Laboratory-grown diamond report: This section includes crucial details about the grading process and the diamond’s basic characteristics. You’ll find:

    • The date the diamond was graded

    • The unique GIA report number

    • Identification confirming it’s a lab-grown diamond

    • Diamond shape and cutting style

    • The diamond’s measurements

  2. Laboratory-grown diamond specifications: This is your quick snapshot of the diamond’s overall attributes. It includes important details like:

    • Carat weight

    • Color grade

    • Clarity grade

    • Cut quality

  3. Additional information and proportions: This section dives deeper into each characteristic. You’ll find:

    • Specific measurements

    • A diagram showing the diamond’s proportions

    • Polish and symmetry grades

    • Fluorescence information

    • Clarity characteristics

    • Any inscriptions on the diamond

GIA lab-grown diamond certification
GIA certification "Laboratory-Grown"

Authenticating GIA Reports

Making sure your GIA report is legit is crucial. Here’s how to do it:

  1. Cross-Check the Report Number: Use GIA’s online report check tool to verify the number on your report.

  2. Look for Laser Inscriptions: Many GIA-certified diamonds have their report number inscribed on their girdles. It’s a direct link between your diamond and its grading report.

Remember, a little due diligence goes a long way in ensuring you’re getting exactly what you paid for.

Diamond serial number

Benefits of Buying GIA Certified Lab-Grown Diamonds

Let’s face it, more and more people are thinking about where their stuff comes from. When it comes to diamonds, ethical sourcing is becoming a big deal. Here’s why lab-grown diamonds are winning hearts:

  • Conflict-Free: Lab-grown diamonds are exactly what they sound like—grown in a lab. No worries about supporting conflict zones or unethical mining practices. They eliminate the ethical concerns associated with ‘blood diamonds’ and conflict financing.

  • Eco-Friendly: Studies show that lab-grown diamonds use significantly fewer natural resources. It’s a conscious choice for those who care about their carbon footprint. In contrast, the environmental impact of a mined diamond is much higher due to extensive mining operations.

  • Transparency: When you choose lab-grown, you know exactly where your diamond came from. No mystery, no doubts.

  • Credibility: Many customers prioritize GIA certification over IGI due to GIA’s established reputation for accuracy and reliability.

  • Current Market Trends: As lab-grown diamonds have risen in popularity, competition has increased. This has driven prices down while maintaining high quality standards. Win-win!

  • Pricing: GIA lab-grown diamonds are sold at 40-70% lower than mined diamonds.

  • Resale Values: Historically, lab-grown diamonds faced some stigma regarding resale value. But let’s set the record straight – Both lab-grown and natural diamonds typically lose 40-60% of their value in the resale market. This isn’t unique to lab diamonds. When you sell to a business, they need to leave room for profit margins. It’s just how the market works. The good news? The resale landscape is changing. As awareness grows and market acceptance increases, resale opportunities are improving for lab-grown diamonds.

2.0 Carat D VS1 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$2,570
$1,285/ct
Underpriced
AFlink
2.0 Carat D VS2 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$2,560
$1,280/ct
Underpriced
AFlink
2.0 Carat D VVS2 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$3,210
$1,605/ct
Underpriced
AFlink

GIA History with Lab-Grown Diamonds

The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) has a long history with lab-grown diamonds. Let’s go back in time:

Early Days (Pre-2007)

From its inception, GIA only graded mined diamonds and gemstones. Lab created diamonds were not part of their grading services.

First Policy (2007)

In 2007 GIA established its first policy for lab created diamonds. But they were still considered “synthetic” not “real” diamonds. The grading process was different from natural diamonds.

Game Changer (2020)

In 2020 GIA announced a new policy for lab created diamonds. This followed the Federal Trade Commission’s decision to classify lab grown diamonds as real diamonds. Here are the key points of this policy:

  1. GIA will grade lab diamonds the same way as natural diamonds.

  2. Reports will indicate the diamond’s origin as “laboratory grown”.

  3. All lab grown diamonds will have a GIA grading report number inscription just like mined diamonds.

  4. The inscription will say “lab grown” for transparency.

  5. Growth properties and specific growth methods will not be disclosed in the reports.

Why the Change

  1. Consumer Demand: GIA’s CEO said consumer interest was the main reason for this policy change.

  2. Education and Trust: The changes are to educate consumers and maintain trust in the gem industry.

  3. Industry Pressure: GIA was pressured by the jewelry industry to offer certification services for lab grown diamonds.

GIA’s View

GIA is an educational and research organization, not an industry advocate. The policy change reflects that.

Industry Politics

You need to understand the politics of the diamond industry:

  • One side sees lab grown diamonds as a legitimate market competitor.

  • The other side sees this as a threat to natural diamonds market share.

Transparency

The new lab grown diamond grading policy will bring more transparency to this part of the diamond industry and address the concerns of clarity and consistency of grading standards.

This is a big deal for the diamond industry, consumer preferences are changing and technology is advancing diamond production.

Where to Buy GIA Certified Diamonds

When you’re ready to buy, choose a reputable retailer. Here are some top picks:

  1. James Allen: Known for their extensive inventory and virtual viewing technology. You can inspect diamonds up close before buying.

  2. Blue Nile: Another big name in the industry. They offer a wide range of certified diamonds and have great educational resources.

  3. Brilliant Earth: Specializes in ethically sourced and sustainable diamonds. Perfect if environmental consciousness is high on your priority list.

  4. Whiteflash: Recognized for high-quality diamonds and exceptional customer service, especially in the online space.

2.01 Carat D VS1 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$2,860
$1,423/ct
Underpriced
AFlink
2.01 Carat D VS2 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$2,860
$1,423/ct
Underpriced
AFlink
2.01 Carat D VS1 Round Cut Lab-Grown Diamond
$2,860
$1,423/ct
Underpriced
AFlink

Conclusion - My Personal Experience

So much has changed in the diamond industry since I started in 2016. I remember when in 2020 the GIA announced their new policy on grading lab created diamonds. Back then lab diamonds were viewed with suspicion and only about 10% of my clients would even consider them as an option.

Lab diamonds had been growing in popularity since 2014 but in 2020 the industry was still very skeptical. But when GIA made their change in policy it was a turning point for the lab diamond market. It was a sign that the most respected laboratory in the industry recognized the shift towards new options.

This has led to a wider acceptance of lab grown diamonds across the industry. The change has been huge: in 2024 over 60% of my clients choose lab grown diamonds. Of those 20% choose GIA and 80% IGI.

This is a big shift in consumer preferences and industry standards. It’s a sign that lab grown diamonds are now a legitimate and desirable option in the diamond market. As we move forward it’s clear that lab grown diamonds are here to stay and giving consumers more choices and changing the way we think about diamond value and authenticity.

Frequently Asked Questions

Let’s be real—GIA lab-grown diamonds typically have a lower resale value compared to natural diamonds. While you might get a better deal upfront, lab-grown diamonds generally lose value faster. Why? They’re more readily available and lack the rarity factor of natural diamonds.

GIA is known for stricter grading standards and consistency, especially for natural diamonds. But when it comes to lab-grown diamonds, the difference is less noticeable. Both GIA and IGI follow similar grading processes for lab-created stones.

You bet! GIA is considered the gold standard for certifying lab-created diamonds. Their reputation for accuracy and reliability in grading is unmatched. GIA evaluates lab-grown diamonds using the same criteria as natural diamonds—the famous four Cs (cut, color, clarity, and carat weight).

GIA diamonds, whether lab-grown or natural, are 100% real diamonds. Don’t let anyone tell you otherwise. Lab-grown diamonds share the same chemical, physical, and optical properties as natural diamonds. They’re made of crystallized carbon and are just as suitable for jewelry as their mined counterparts. The only difference? Their origin story.

SHOP MY #1 TOP RATED
DIAMOND PROVIDER

DEAL ALERT!

SAVE 25% ON STUDS & EARRINGS | 10% OFF SELECTED LAB-GROWN DIAMONDS

PRINCESS CUT DIAMOND

Do you want help picking the best diamond?